Who this guide is for
This guide is for CIOs, chief AI officers, heads of operations, risk leaders and enterprise architects who have to choose how AI agents will run in production. It gives you twelve questions to put to any vendor, including us, and a way to test the answers on one real workflow.
Why the choice matters now
Three facts frame the decision.
- Gartner predicts that over 40% of agentic AI projects will be canceled by the end of 2027, citing escalating costs, unclear business value or inadequate risk controls.
- The same Gartner release warns of "agent washing" and estimates that only about 130 of the thousands of agentic AI vendors are real.
- In the European Union, obligations for stand-alone high-risk AI systems now apply from 2 December 2027, after the Digital Omnibus moved the date (CMS). The extra time is for preparation, not a pause.
The projects that survive will be the ones that can show what their agents did, under whose authority, and at what cost.
What an Agentic OS is
An Agentic OS is the operating layer that turns a business goal into a plan, coordinates agents, and carries out the work across enterprise systems under policy, with a record of every step. It is different from a copilot, which assists a person, and from an agent builder, which helps you create agents but does not govern how they run. For a category comparison, see Agentic OS vs Copilot vs RPA.
The twelve questions
1. Execution: does it finish the work?
| Question to ask | Why it matters | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Can it carry out a whole workflow across two or more of our systems? | Value comes from finished work, not suggestions. | A live run on your own workflow, across your own systems. |
| 2. What happens when a step fails halfway? | Partial work is where incidents start. | A defined retry, rollback or hand-off to a person, shown in the demo. |
| 3. Does the agent keep context between tasks? | Without memory every task starts from zero. | Persistent memory with rules on what is kept and for how long. |
2. Control: who decides what an agent may do?
| Question to ask | Why it matters | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 4. Can we set autonomy per agent and per action? | One global setting is too coarse for real work. | Limits you configure yourself, by action type and value. |
| 5. What happens above our approval limit? | This is the control regulators and boards ask about. | The action stops and waits for a named approver. |
| 6. Can it stop an agent from another vendor? | Seeing an agent is not the same as controlling it. | A demonstration of a third-party agent being blocked, not only listed. |
3. Evidence: can we prove what happened?
| Question to ask | Why it matters | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 7. What record is kept for each action? | Audit needs the reason as well as the result. | A decision trace: inputs, policy applied, approver and outcome. |
| 8. Can our auditors read it without the vendor? | Evidence you cannot read is not evidence. | Export in a form your audit team already uses. |
4. Fit: will it work in our landscape?
| Question to ask | Why it matters | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 9. Which of our enterprise systems does it already work with? | Integration is where most agent projects stall. | Reference designs for your core systems, such as SAP, Oracle, Workday, ServiceNow or Dynamics. |
| 10. Where does it run, and where does our data go? | Sovereignty and residency rules differ by country and sector. | Deployment options that match your cloud and residency requirements, stated in writing. |
5. Commercials: what will it cost to run?
| Question to ask | Why it matters | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 11. How is it priced as usage grows? | Agent costs rise with volume, and surprises kill projects. | A cost model you can run with your own volumes before you sign. |
| 12. How do we leave? | Lock-in is easiest to negotiate before you buy. | Your policies, records and workflow definitions are exportable. |
Red flags
- The demo shows a chat window but never completes a transaction in a real system.
- Governance means a dashboard, with no way to stop an action before it happens.
- Performance figures are quoted with no customer, method or source behind them.
- The vendor cannot say where the audit record is stored or how long it is kept.
How to test the answers
- Pick one workflow that crosses at least two systems and has a clear approval step.
- Write down the limit above which a person must approve.
- Ask each vendor to run the workflow, including one case above the limit and one case that fails.
- Ask for the record of both cases and give it to your audit team to read.
- Run your expected volumes through the pricing model.
A vendor that can do this on your workflow has answered most of the twelve questions. To estimate running cost, you can start with the Agentic OS cost calculator.
Where ElixirClaw fits
ElixirClaw is an Agentic OS for governed agent execution. Digital Workers carry out work across your existing systems. You set the autonomy level per agent and per action, anything above your approval limits waits for a named approver, and every action leaves a decision trace your audit team can read. The same policies apply to ElixirClaw Digital Workers, third-party agents and the agents your teams build. Reference designs are available as blueprints for SAP, Oracle Fusion, Workday, ServiceNow, Microsoft Dynamics 365 and Infor.
Put the twelve questions to us as well. That is the point of the guide.
Frequently asked questions
Should we buy an Agentic OS or use the agent tools from our main software vendor?
If one platform runs most of the work, start there. If workflows cross several systems, you will need a cross-system runtime as well. See Agentic OS vs vendor agent control planes.
How long should an evaluation take?
Long enough to run one real workflow end to end, including an approval and a failure. A slide review will not answer the questions above.
Who should be in the evaluation team?
The owner of the workflow, an enterprise architect, and someone from risk or audit. The audit view is the one most often added too late.
Next step
Book an architecture review. We take one of your workflows and map it to autonomy levels, approval limits and an audit trail, so you can see the answers to these questions on your own work. You can also read how the Agentic OS supports enterprise AI operations.